Arizona Needs to MIne Black Mesa :: Counter Argument

To the northeastern part of Arizona lay a debacle between the Native American citizens and a sear dig company known as Peabody blacken. In the seemingly unending date between the two groups, the problem began in 1968 when the Hopi and Navajo tribes both signed leases to Peabody char for mining. The contract included paying both tribes more than $1000 per acre-foot of congenital aquifer peeing each year (Peabody Energy Online par 4). As while drew on, many indigenous commonwealth were alarmed that the water was heedlessly being depleted from their land. Mining on Black Mesa should all the same be kept in progress because Peabody Coal helps support the conflict against high-cost electricity, recent findings have stipulated that mining on Black Mesa is not as potentially harmful as many would like to telephone it is, and it offers jobs to the local economy. If a group of people give certain privileges to another, and the affects of it read to help the economic society surrounded by it, there actually is not a problem. Black Mesa, a natural resource for water is still being occupied by Peabody Coal, the fields largest coal company. Located on the Navajo and Hopi Reservations of Northern Arizona, the mining company pumps water appear of the Navajo Aquifer (N-Aquifer) which is mixed with grated coal known as slurry. The slurry is then pumped through a pipeline to Nevadas Mohave Generating Station where it is converted into low-cost electricity (Peabody Energy Online par 3). Peabody has two mines on Black Mesa which includes the Peabody Coal Mine as well as the Kayenta Mine, both help to modernize enough coal that supports 1.5 million people in the Southwest including Arizona, Nevada, and atomic number 20 (Peabody Energy Online par 8). The low-cost electricity is quite affordable for the people who live in the area. Peabody Coal has many coal mines around the world which help fight to keep the cost of energy down.Peabody Coal had say that they do respect the values and beliefs of the native people that occupy the reservations. In that sense, the coal company consoled the U.S. Department of the Interiors Office of scrape Mining for concerned questions about the usage of the groundwater. According to the OMS 2004 annual report, the N-Aquifer is in a stable condition, the quality is still excellent, and streams that were presumed to be in an smooth condition due to the mining, is not the cause